RECESSIONAL HYMN – FOR AND AGAINST

choir-clipartThose at the Parish Assembly would have noted that Mt Lion Neighbourhood proposed Recessionals (leaving hymn….ed) be part of the Mass. At the Liturgy Meeting on Tuesday night, it was discussed and decided that an uplifting instrumental piece be used at the end of each Mass. This will be reviewed at our next meeting.

A note from a document that was prepared for Westminster diocese “At Your Word Lord” process by the Liturgy Office of the Bishops’ Conference of England and Wales © 2005 Liturgy Office, Bishops’ Conference of England and Wales.

In the Roman Rite of Mass the final hymn is not mentioned neither in the Missal or the General Instruction. It is an accretion which was added when the ‘four-hymn sandwich’ was introduced as way of encouraging people to sing at Mass in the vernacular when there was not other material to enable the singing of the liturgy itself.
Experience shapes expectations. We tend to believe that what we have done is right and that we cannot imagine alternatives. But having already been fed by word and sacrament, is there in fact need for a further song before we give ourselves to our mission to love and serve the Lord?
What might happen?
The final song of the Mass, according to the Missal, is the song of thanksgiving after communion. After everyone responds ‘Thanks be to God’ to the dismissal they process out, perhaps to joyful instrumental music, led by priest and ministers. There is chance to talk to one another outside before beginning a new week strengthened by word and Eucharist.
What are the advantages and disadvantages of a final hymn?
    For: we are used to it; it rounds things off nicely. It gives another opportunity for picking up the themes we have identified. It covers the procession. We enjoy it.

   Against: it prevents us responding immediately in both words and action to the dismissal. It is padding. Half the congregation have left anyway.

What might we do?
It would be a real challenge for many parishes to move from a final hymn to a procession out together. Like many changes it would require cooperation of the priest and other ministers together with careful preparation, and catechesis. It would be important to respect that some members of assembly may wish to stay where they are.
As mentioned above it is an ideal opportunity for music from an organ or other instruments. The other possibility is to sing a short song or chant. Like singing in the communion procession whatever is sung should not need books or sheets.

Leave comments below

Advertisements

2 Replies to “RECESSIONAL HYMN – FOR AND AGAINST”

  1. IN ANSWER TO THE QUESTIONS POSED ABOVE:

  2. is there in fact need for a further song before we give ourselves to our mission to love and serve the Lord? CAN WE NOT LOVE AND SERVE OUR LORD WITH JOYFUL SONG AS SOON AS THE MASS IS ENDED WHEN THE PRIEST OR DEACON SAYS “GO FORTH, THE MASS IS ENDED.”(or one of the other Dismissal commands)
  3. After everyone responds ‘Thanks be to God’ to the dismissal they process out, perhaps to joyful instrumental music. JOYFUL INSTRUMENTAL MUSIC IS GOOD, JOYFUL SINGING IS BAD? THAT IS TOO SILLY FOR RESPONSE.
  4. The other possibility is to sing a short song or chant. Like singing in the communion procession whatever is sung should not need books or sheets. IS THAT NOT WHAT WE WANT TO DO? DOES THE ARGUMENT COME DOWN TO THE NEED FOR A HYMN SHEET OR HYMN BOOK, IF SO LET’S DO IT
  5. If one looks in the back of any Hymnal they will find a whole category of Hymns under the heading Recessional. This is yet another example of the tail wagging the dog. Rather than the celibate church listening to those who wish to finish with a Hymn, they wish to again impose their will on the faithful. It’s time the celibate church realized that the Body of Christ, the congregation, also has a point of view of equal value to theirs and they are there to serve us, not vice versa!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s